LucidRents
RankingsLandlordsNeighborhoods
Write Review
Log in

Lucid Rents

Know your New York City apartment before you sign. Real data, real reviews, real transparency.

[email protected]

Navigation

  • Search Buildings
  • Submit a Review
  • New York City Housing News
  • About
  • Contact

Data Sources

  • NYC Open Data - HPD Violations
  • NYC Open Data - DOB Violations
  • NYC Open Data - 311 Complaints
  • NYC PLUTO Building Data

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Resources

  • Rent affordability calculator
  • Rent timing calculator
  • Tenant tools
  • Know your rights

© 2026 Lucid Rents. All rights reserved. · Privacy · Terms · Admin

HomeNeighborhoodsCity Island
A
4.9/5

City Island Report Card

10464 · Bronx · 1,255 buildings tracked

A

Building Quality

Average building score

A

Safety

Based on violent crime rate

B

Maintenance

Violations per building

A

Responsiveness

Complaints per building

Buildings

1,255

Violations

1,952

Complaints

560

Reviews

5

Crime Summary (12 Months)

165

Total Incidents

20

Violent

35

Property

110

Quality of Life

View detailed crime data

Neighborhood Pulse

Low Activity
Violations/Bldg

1.6

Below avg

Complaints/Bldg

0.4

Below avg

Reviews

5

Tenant reviews

Crime (12mo)

165

Total incidents

Monthly Rent Trends

Median rent with 25th-75th percentile range

Based on listing data. Shaded area shows 25th-75th percentile range.

Most Flagged Buildings

C

452 CITY ISLAND AVENUE, Bronx, NY, 10464

331 violations42 complaints
B

456 CITY ISLAND AVENUE, Bronx, NY, 10464

245 violations154 complaints
B

185 CITY ISLAND AVENUE, Bronx, NY, 10464

182 violations45 complaints
C

183 CITY ISLAND AVENUE, Bronx, NY, 10464

127 violations38 complaints
B

2 WINDWARD LANE, Bronx, NY, 10464

98 violations10 complaints

Largest Landlord

BURTON MARY S

6 buildings in this zip code

View landlord portfolio

City Island Vibe Check

City Island is the Bronx's best-kept secret — a tiny New England-style fishing village jutting into Long Island Sound. Seafood restaurants line the main street, sailboats bob in the harbor, and the pace of life is nothing like the city just a bridge away.

Coastal VillageSeafoodQuirkyQuietHidden Gem

Pros

  • ✓Waterfront seafood restaurants
  • ✓Small-town atmosphere
  • ✓Boating and fishing culture
  • ✓Pelham Bay Park access

Cons

  • ✗Very car-dependent
  • ✗No subway access
  • ✗Limited housing stock
Compare City Island with another neighborhood

Frequently Asked Questions About City Island

8 questions answered

In the last 12 months, the 10464 zip code had 165 reported crime incidents, including 20 violent crimes and 35 property crimes. The area receives a safety score of 4.5 out of 5. Check the full crime breakdown on Lucid Rents for details.

City Island (10464) has 1,255 tracked buildings with an average building quality score of 4.9 out of 5. Building scores are based on violations, complaints, and tenant reviews.

Buildings in the 10464 zip code have a combined 1,952 housing violations on record (an average of 1.6 per building). You can browse individual buildings on Lucid Rents to see their specific violation history.

The largest landlord in City Island (10464) is BURTON MARY S, managing 6 buildings in this zip code. View their full portfolio and tenant reviews on Lucid Rents.

Tenants have submitted 5 reviews across 5 buildings in City Island (10464). Read firsthand experiences about building quality, management responsiveness, and neighborhood life on Lucid Rents.

City Island (10464) has 1,255 tracked buildings with 1,952 violations and 560 complaints. Visit the Lucid Rents neighborhood rankings to see how City Island (10464) compares to other NYC neighborhoods by safety, building quality, and maintenance.

City Island (10464) recorded 165 crime incidents over the past 12 months: 20 violent crimes, 35 property crimes, and 110 quality-of-life incidents. See the full trend data on the Lucid Rents crime page for 10464.

Many buildings in NYC have rent-stabilized units. Browse buildings in City Island (10464) on Lucid Rents to check the rent stabilization status of individual buildings in the 10464 zip code.

Nearby & Similar Neighborhoods

B

Highbridge

10452 · Bronx

1,136 buildings

B

University Heights

10468 · Bronx

1,406 buildings

B

Morris Heights

10453 · Bronx

1,762 buildings

B

Fordham

10458 · Bronx

2,685 buildings

Demographics

U.S. Census ACS estimates

Population

4,292

Median Income

$129k

Renters

34%

Median Age

49.4

Walkability & Transit

20

Limited Transit

19 transit stops nearby

18

Bus Stops

Neighborhood Rankings

Safer than 86% of neighborhoods

Fewer violations than 1% of neighborhoods

Better rated than 89% of neighborhoods